James Wilson on the Role of Reason and Virtue in Women

1 wilson james oval sm

As a successful lawyer and brilliant philosophical mind, Founding Father James Wilson is best remembered for his legal theory. Yet a crucial, although often understudied area of his scholarship is his many writings about women. For Wilson, championing the rights of women is more than just some kind-hearted nod to a historically second-class group. Rather, since Wilson believes that politics is predicated on our conception of human nature, our choosing to omit, or even purposely neglect, any one part of this nature, such as women, is willfully limiting the full flourishing of government. A just conception of politics necessitates a just conception of women. In this piece, I will focus on three key dimensions of Wilson’s ideas on women: (1) as individuals, (2) as members of society, and (3), as examples for the political order.

Wilson’s most robust explanation of women as individuals, and indeed, his first recorded instance writing on women at all, is, admittedly, rather unconventional. In February of 1768, he co-founded an anonymous column in The Pennsylvania Chronicle with friend William White titled “The Visitant,” which began as a series of weekly reflections on the happiness and nature of man. As the publication evolved, however, it became almost exclusively a forum for advice—with avid readers, chiefly young men, writing in with questions of their own. Perhaps unsurprisingly, these queries quickly shifted to discussions about the fair sex. Although as a genre, writing about women was far from unique to Wilson—indeed, only six years prior, the French philosopher Jean Jacques Rousseau released his famous work on the education of the sexes, Emile—“The Visitant” proved novel in how it presented the female character. Wilson, far from agreeing with what he perceived to be the frequent devaluation, and subsequent misrepresentation of feminine capabilities, opens the third installment of “the Visitant” with the lament: “How often is it pretended that women have little minds”! [1]

Yet, far from conceding a natural deficiency to women, Wilson blames their apparent superficiality on the mode of education they have been conditioned to receive. Limited to a formation focused only on “the external accomplishments of dress and behavior,” [2] Wilson opines, “while these are the standard of female merit, no wonder if they are taught to use all their efforts to excel in what will make them appear to advantage in the world . . . the mind accustomed to apply to trifling objects, in a short time becomes vain and trifling itself.” [3] But Wilson uses such false conceptions of women as springboards towards his own views—namely, that women are creatures rooted in reason and oriented toward virtue. “If a lady would acquire esteem, she should cultivate those virtues which render the female mind amiable, and give importance to the sex,” he writes.[4] Devoting herself to the measured practice of “good sense, improved by reading . . . united with the amiable virtues,” [5] only by such careful attention to the cultivation of the mind, brought to perfection by pursuit of virtue, can a woman attain the proper treatment that Wilson so firmly desired for her.

In May of 1768, “The Visitant” ended—and with it, it seemed, Wilson’s interest in the study of women. However, his attention to the importance of the female sex made an unexpected and prominent return. After delivering a particularly rousing summons on the role of education in civic formation in the first of his Lectures on Law on December 15, 1790, Wilson takes what appears to be a sudden and unrelated shift in topic: “Methinks I hear one of the female part of my audience exclaim — What is all this to us?” he exclaims, continuing, “We have heard much of societies, of states, of governments, of laws, and of a law education. Is every thing made for your sex? Why should not we have a share? Is our sex less honest, or less virtuous, or less wise than yours?” [6] Giving voice, once again, to the needs and concerns of the female sex, it seems our valorous Visitant has returned.

Although building in many ways upon the ideas of his previous writings, the vision of women Wilson articulates in his lecture is much more communal and concerned with politics as such. Invoking the formidable governance by women such as Semiramis of Nineveh,[7] Zenobia, Queen of the East,[8] and Queen Elizabeth I of England, he claims that when one appeals to history, there is no shortage of women whose professional accomplishments equal, or even surpass that of men. Yet he claims that it is not for their leadership alone that such women have garnered his respect. Instead, returning to his original theme of the origin and purpose of the law, Wilson addresses the ladies with the following exhortation: “You have, indeed, heard much of publick government and publick law: but these things were not made for themselves: they were made for something better; and of that something better, you form the better part — I mean society.” [9]

By deliberately linking the issues of women with those of politics, Wilson performs a rhetorically masterful move. Through this essay, Wilson not only addresses the concerns of the women in his audience, but he also demonstrates to the rest of his listeners how our understanding of the human being is inextricably intertwined with politics. His argument goes as such: Because we place too high of a value on law and government, we tend also to herald its various visible arbiters, such as statesmen or lawyers. But this is exactly backwards. Going on to assert that it is society, not government, which is at the heart of the political body, Wilson asserts that we ought to transfer our praise instead to the many courageous individuals who perform the crucial, though often thankless work that is the formation and preservation of society. Almost overwhelmingly, these individuals are women.

Although such statements could be interpreted as restrictive of women’s political contributions, the examples which Wilson then proceeds to give directly after his remarks show the contrary. First, calling a robust education for women “an employment of so much dignity, that ladies of the first rank did not disdain it,” [10] Wilson then sings the praises of Laelia,[11] a woman “sought after by “the first speakers of the age” [12] and “whose virtues and accomplishments rendered her one of the principal ornaments of Rome.” [13] Far from conceding that women possess a second-class status in the political order, then, Wilson asserts exactly the contrary: It is women who represent the very bedrock of the American republic. Devaluing their contributions necessarily means devaluing the political order.

The final, and arguably most striking reflection of Wilson on the role of women in politics comes in his section, “Man, as a Member of Society.” Here Wilson once again articulates the importance of society to man’s flourishing, yet this time he does so through the lens of mutual, embodied dependence. All human beings, he claims, are fundamentally needy. This is both a natural and necessary good. “Society supposes mutual dependence,” he claims, “mutual dependence supposes mutual wants: all the social exercises and enjoyments may be reduced to two heads — that of giving, and that of receiving.” [14] Given his previous championing of women as models for political society, it is no surprise that Wilson holds up a mother and her child as his model. “[Man] is capable of social intercourse long before he is capable of reasoning,” he says, “He can, by signs, ask and refuse, threaten and supplicate. In danger, he clings to his mother . . . he enters into her joy and grief, is happy in her caresses, and is unhappy in her displeasure. As sociability attends us in our infancy; she continues to be our companion through all the variegated scenes of our riper years.” [15] Far from seeing this mode of existence as bad, or saying that it is an injustice which we ought to overcome, Wilson asserts the contrary: a good society, following the example of women, is built on the sharing and care of needs.  

As we finish celebrating the United States’ semiquincentennial, James Wilson holds much that is worthy of our consideration as Americans today. Championing the role of reason and virtue in women against their detractors, he simultaneously argues for a renewal of appreciation for the role of women in the political order. Recognizing the myriad ways in which women contribute to the building up of society, he concludes by drawing from their example a witness to the rest of the political body. As we continue to evaluate the role and application of the Founders’ vision today, we would do well to learn from the lessons Wilson taught championing the rights of women.


[1] Wilson, “The Visitant,” No. III, https://colenda.library.upenn.edu/catalog/81431-p3db7ws0w

[2] Wilson, “The Visitant,” No. VII, https://colenda.library.upenn.edu/catalog/81431-p3db7ws0w

[3] Wilson, “The Visitant,” No. III,  https://colenda.library.upenn.edu/catalog/81431-p3db7ws0w

[4] Wilson, “The Visitant,” No. VII, https://colenda.library.upenn.edu/catalog/81431-p3db7ws0w

[5] Wilson, “The Visitant,” No. III, https://colenda.library.upenn.edu/catalog/81431-p3db7ws0w

[6] Wilson, Lectures on Law, “Of the Study of Law in the United States,” pg. 85

[7] A legendary warrior queen, who restored ancient Babylon

[8] Queen of the Palmyrene Empire in the third century

[9] Wilson, Lectures on Law, “Of the Study of Law in the United States,” pg. 86

[10] Wilson, Lectures on Law, “Of the Study of Law in the United States,” pg. 88

[11] Wife of famous Roman Marcus Scaevola, who was admired by Cicero for her impressive eloquence

[12] Wilson, Lectures on Law, “Of the Study of Law in the United States,” pg. 89

[13] Ibid

[14] Wilson, Lectures on Law, “Man, as a Member of Society,” pg. 239

[15] Wilson, Lectures on Law, “Man, as a Member of Society,” pg. 234

Elizabeth Mitchell is an undergraduate student at the University of Notre Dame. She was an intern with the James Wilson Institute.
Anchoring Truths
Anchoring Truths is a James Wilson Institute project
The James Wilson Institute’s Mission is to restore to a new generation of lawyers, judges, and citizens the understanding of the American Founders about the first principles of our law and the moral grounds of their own rights.
Learn More